The problem with “one size fits all” vs. niche MMOs

(Hi, I’m back! I have moved to America, and unpacked my boxes! And played games! I missed blogging, you guys. <3 )

Brianna Royce over at Massively wrote an interesting editorial today titled, "Working As Intended: Niche MMOs vs. the everything box“. In it she argues that the MMO industry’s present slide towards niche MMOs will hurt the genre overall, creating games with smaller and less diverse player bases. It’s an interesting essay, and worth a read.

I agree with a number of the fundamentals of Royce’s argument: having many niche MMOs will absolutely fracture players, and takes away a lot of that “massive” feeling that drew many of us to the genre in the first place. Niche games lack diversity of purpose, and you’re less likely to encounter a variety of players. And if a game chooses a niche that is not as populated as the developers think (Royce points out WildStar and hardcore raiders here), they’re on a fast track to failuretown.

There’s one big problem with the essay’s conclusion though, and it’s this: we only need one “everything box” MMO.

If you have one game that tries to provide opportunities and fun for a huge variety of playstyles (a noble goal to be sure!), well… by its very definition that would remove the need for a second “everything box”. If you need a second game, the first one clearly isn’t being everything.

In fact, I would argue that this has been the exact problem in the MMO industry since the rise of WoW. When every game is trying to be all things to all players, what’s the difference between them? So we rush from one new game to the next, only to find that, yep, at its core it’s “just like WoW” or “just like EQ” or whatever your first alpha and omega MMO happened to be. Oh well, on to the next new title!

(And that’s not even getting into the fact that creating a game that encompasses “everything” is prohibitively expensive, particularly in the current MMO economic climate.)

I appreciate Royce’s motivations for her piece — putting the massive back in MMOs, and making them a more well rounded virtual world — but I feel like unfortunately that dream might be left behind with the days when there were only one or two big games to play. With big “everything box” games like Guild Wars 2 and WoW and EverQuest II already available, what’s the point in just adding more to the pile?

Cat Context 63: SWTOR levelling, Alien: Isolation, ArcheAge drama
Nov13

Cat Context 63: SWTOR levelling, Alien: Isolation, ArcheAge drama

cat context vertical Cat Context 63: SWTOR levelling, Alien: Isolation, ArcheAge drama

This week Ellyndrial and Arolaide were joined by special guest Corranhorn for a Liore-free show!

Elly looks back at this year’s wildly successful Extra Life Marathon, and talks about some of the games he played including Alien: Isolation and Euro Truck Simulator. He also finally had the opportunity to watch the movie Alien, and the crew discusses how the movie stands up to a new audience and whether it enhances the game experience.

Meanwhile Arolaide has been enjoying the pre-expansion XP boost in Star Wars: The Old Republic! Players are able to skip most if not all of the side quests and just enjoy the precious, precious class story. As usual though playing SWTOR is a mixed blessing, and the game swings manically from awesome to terrible and back again.

Corr regales the podcast with some tales of life in ArcheAge, including guild drama and the crazy lengths players need to go to protect their precious land assets. Get land or die tryin’!

Like to watch? This podcast has a livestreamed video version:

If you enjoyed this podcast, please “Like” or “Favorite” it in your media consumption method of choice! It makes us feel nice.

* Free Music Archive page for our theme, in THE crowd by The Years

Cat Context 62: Gettin’ Scared with Spooky Games and Movies
Oct22

Cat Context 62: Gettin’ Scared with Spooky Games and Movies

(Hey, want to hear more podcasts with me on them? Of course you do! Check out the latest episode of Contains Moderate Peril where I guest along with Mr. Murf in a discussion about open world PvP. And if you like these shows, visit The Gaming and Entertainment Network for other great podcasts!)

cat context vertical Cat Context 62: Gettin Scared with Spooky Games and Movies

It’s almost Halloween, and this week Liore, Ellyndrial, and Arolaide sit down to talk about scary games, spooky movies, and what gets our hearts pounding and our adrenaline rising.

Liore starts the discussion with a confession: she loves scary movies, but has a hard time playing scary games. Meanwhile Aro chimes in with some of her favorite scary games (hint: Silent Hill 2 comes up a lot), and Elly comments on the different kinds of “scary”, from plain old gore to more intellectual ennui.

We love zombies but agree that they’re handled pretty poorly in movies and potentially less so in games (same with vampires). And scary space stories — we want more of those in both games and movies, but perhaps the necessary design restrictions of games makes it difficult to convey being alone in space? No matter what, we think games should look to scary movies when considering pacing.

Also, Elly hasn’t seen Alien! Aro is unconvinced about scary games with no weapons at all! Liore is sooooo bored of modern grimdark horror!

Like to watch? This podcast has a livestreamed video version:

If you enjoyed this podcast, please “Like” or “Favorite” it in your media consumption method of choice! It makes us feel nice.

* Free Music Archive page for our theme, in THE crowd by The Years

Extra Life is this weekend!!

We interrupt sporadic postings about horror movies to tell you that EXTRA LIFE IS THIS WEEKEND!

What does that mean? Well first, please donate! We’ve raised $460, or 77% of my goal! All donations are tax deductible and go to the Children’s Hospital of BC.

What else? Well on Saturday, the day of the marathon, I will be giving away a ton of games including a Digital Deluxe version of Guild Wars 2! (Thanks again, Arenanet.) I’ll be giving away games to donators and fellow marathoners on Twitter or on the on the Twitch stream the day of the marathon. (The copy of Guild Wars 2 is for donators only!)

And if you’re looking for more streams the day of the marathon, check out Ellyndrial’s stream or the Alliance of Awesome team on Hitbox which includes fellow bloggers Belghast and Braxwolf.

Extra Life is a lot of fun, and a great cause, and any way you can get involved will help.

Spooky Trailers: Candyman (1992) and You’re Next (2011)

It’s October, the spookiest month! I love horror movies, so for October I’m going to be highlighting some of my older or lesser known favorites thanks to YouTube’s huge backlog of trailers. I also add a “scary rating” for folks who like a little fright but not a full on horror fest.

Rating: R
How Intense Is It?: 6/10

Candyman, Candyman, Candyman! One of the best adaptations of a Clive Barker story, Candyman is a slasher movie dressed up in a critique of a topic usually too scary for even the most hardened horror director: modern (American) race relations. I think the movie is right in some ways and really off the mark in others, but it’s a deft combination of social commentary and super bloody horror that we don’t often see.


Rating: R
How Intense Is It?: 8/10

You’re Next is a slasher movie for people who love slasher movies. It somehow manages to embrace all of the tropes, while still portraying them in a way that feels fresh. We know the dance moves, but we’ve never done them to this beat. And on top of it all you can just feel the love everyone involved in this movie (a product of the new “Mumblegore” school of American indie horror, a movement I adore) has for the genre. Even when horrible things are happening to nice people on your TV screen, you will have to work hard to suppress a grin of delight.

Page 6 of 117« First...45678...Last »
%d bloggers like this: